Fiddler urges Ottawa to honour treaties at First Nations-First Ministers’ Meeting
Alvin Fiddler, Grand Chief of Nishnawbe Aski Nation (NAN), urged federal and provincial leaders to honour treaty commitments and address longstanding crises in First Nations communities during a First Nations-First Ministers’ Meeting in Ottawa on Tuesday.
Fiddler said he wrote to Prime Minister Mark Carney and Ontario Premier Doug Ford last September requesting a meeting with NAN leadership to discuss the challenges facing northern First Nations.
“Our communities face these pressures while losing young people to addictions and suicide, and while trying to address the impacts of climate change, as we saw this summer with forest fires and evacuations. They are trying to navigate systems that are supposed to be there for them, like healthcare. Those systems are failing them.”
— Alvin Fiddler
The death of Miranda Mamakwa, a mother of three from Fort Severn First Nation, was mentioned by Fiddler as an example of failures in the health care system.
After open-heart surgery, Mamakwa was scheduled for four follow-up appointments from May to June this summer.
NAN and the Sioux Lookout First Nations Health Authority (SLFNHA) allege the Non-Insured Health Benefits program failed to arrange the required travel and accommodations.
Mamakwa was airlifted from Fort Severn to Thunder Bay for emergency treatment on September 8, where she later died.
“Miranda Mamakwa should still be here today, raising her three children,” said SLFNHA President and CEO Sonia Isaac-Mann on September 11. “Her death is not something that simply happened to her, it is the result of a system that failed her, appointment after appointment, for months.”
Fiddler said First Nations are being asked to participate in major development projects, including those connected to the Ring of Fire region, while still addressing basic infrastructure and service needs within their communities.
“Our communities are navigating challenges while dealing with pressure to open up their lands and territories. The Ring of Fire is just one example. How can you expect a community like Marten Falls to effectively negotiate a meaningful agreement while trying to access clean water for themselves? They have been on the boil water advisory list since 2004. The same as my community.”
— Alvin Fiddler
Fiddler’s central message to the Prime Minister and premiers was that treaties should not be viewed as barriers to economic development.
Instead, he said they should be seen as the foundation of the relationship between First Nations and governments.
He urged leaders to honour and implement treaties, arguing that the agreements were intended to create peaceful coexistence, mutual benefit and shared prosperity.
“We do not need to create new policy to find a prosperous path forward,” Fiddler said. “All you have to do is honour the Treaties.”
The meeting brought together First Nations leaders, the federal government and provincial premiers to discuss economic development, reconciliation and shared priorities across the country.


